Is the VXX Vulnerable Right Here?

The VXX is now holding all July futures. Here is how they stand:

Symbol Contract Month Time Last Change Open High Low
VX M3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY June2013 16:38:09 16.80 -0.19 16.80 17.10 16.65
VX N3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY July2013 16:38:08 17.65 -0.17 17.80 17.88 17.55
VX Q3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY August2013 16:38:08 18.35 -0.25 18.50 18.57 18.25

Meanwhile the VIX closed today at 16.60, which is where July basically sits, and with good reason:

VIX Volatility Index values generated at:  06/18/2013 15:14:55

Trade Date Expiration Date VIX Contract Month
6/18/2013 3:14:55 PM
20-Jul-13
16.63 1
6/18/2013 3:14:55 PM
17-Aug-13
17.06 2

So the futures premium to spot July is roughly 6%. It is very possible that you could see what I call a “volatility exhale” tomorrow after the Fed meeting, just for the simple fact that it is over. This frequently occurs when there is an event that has the market’s keen attention, and because the VXX is holding all of the front month, it can move up or down a lot faster than when it has rolled a significant portion to the next month at a higher price. The farther month tends to act as a sort of an automatic stabilizer.

It would not be out of the ordinary to see a 10% move lower this week in the VXX. The market would have to cooperate and remain quiet to higher for this to happen, and a sell-the-news reaction is certainly a possibility. But with the SPY far from overbought, the MACD curling up, and price moving above the 10 day SMA, it seems to be set for a retest of the highs.

The last days of the opex cycle and the early ones of the next cycle generally see the lowest volatility. The VXX has seen many big moves lower during these stretches in the cycle. As recently as April, the VXX fell $3 as the VIX went from 17.5 to 13.5 in three days at the end of the cycle. If the VIX fell to 15 and the July future maintained an .80 cent spread to spot, that right there is $2 lower in the VXX.

VXX option chain:

vxx618

The plan is to try to find a small spike in vol tomorrow to leg into the $21 puts at a lower price. The reason I like this strike is because you don’t need the VXX to move to maintain most of your capital, yet if it does you have a high delta for speedy profit. The lower strikes are not cheap, but they could pay handsomely provided the VXX moves sharply lower. The VXX puts for next week are just too expensive, even at $21. It is all about the Fed meeting on this trade.

As a sidenote, the SPY weekly puts are showing very high implied vol, so we started a put diagonal:

SPY option chain, weekly:

spy621

WIth the weekly SPY puts showing an IV of 23, the 1640 puts were sold for .85. Paired with next week’s 1630, the diagonal price was .25. If the S&P does not absolutely crater tomorrow, the short puts will evaporate into thin air and next week’s puts will be gravy to hold for a few day or to sell for a quick profit.

Interestingly, the SPX puts show lower implied volatility:

spx621

If anyone can explain that phenomenon, I would love to learn something. TIA.

VIX Shrugs Off Late Day Spike

We are back in those days again, when weak speculation on the basis of absolutely nothing by nobodies near a news wire can evaporate 15 S&P points in a half hour. Tape bombing by “reporters”, to either make a name for themselves, or to get paid by HFT news algorithms is a fact of today’s market life, especially when low volume allows these tactics to have the greatest effect. Amazing how journalists used to get facts and sources, now they say whatever they want. This is not limited to financial journalists, as recent episodes on CNN make it clear that facts are a secondary requirement of news.

Anyway, the VIX while fresh into its new near and next month structure, (July and August) currently sits at a value below both months, as the VIN and VIF are higher than the VIX. Sixfigureinvesting.com does a fantastic job explaining the nuances of this part of the opex cycle, and how it affects the VIX:

http://sixfigureinvesting.com/2013/05/calculating-vix-the-easy-part/

“The chart below shows the calculation on the next trading day when VIN switches to June options and VIF uses July options.  Notice how the green VIX bar is now to the left of the blue VIN bar.”

VIX calculation for 22-May-2013

(It may have been implied by my last post that you can take the number of days and arrive at a VIX calculation weighting the August days as a negative weighting for this week and the July days at a premium using the time remaining in the respective cycle for each, but this is not the case. I won’t get into the hard specifics of variance vs. standard deviation and their effects on the VIX formula vis a vis the time factor, but Vance does this with terrific clarity in his post, referenced above. Suffice it to say that you can roughly ballpark it just knowing the VIN, VIF and where you are in the opex cycle.)

The old “volatility is here to stay” nonsense is back, and if there is one thing we know for sure, it is that it is not, because it never is. It costs money to drive up implied volatility, and it won’t happen forever. The last time it was here to stay was in December during the stand-off in D.C., and it promptly disappeared as fast as Alaska snow in 90 degree weather. (http://www.accuweather.com/en/weather-news/heat-turns-up-in-alaska-1/14371788)

The VIX futures expire tomorrow, and the Wednesday open is alway interesting to watch due to the rumored shenanigans at settlement with the opening quotes.  The VIX curve looks surprisingly normal, not far from historical patterns and upward sloping, so this volatility is not that out of the ordinary:

Symbol Contract Month Time Last Change Open High Low
VX M3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY June2013 16:15:00 16.90 -0.65 17.00 17.53 16.53
VX N3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY July2013 16:15:00 17.80 -0.50 17.90 18.19 17.65
VX Q3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY August2013 16:15:00 18.55 -0.35 18.50 18.75 18.31

2013-06-10 20_46_09-Microsoft Excel non-commercial use - VIX-Wave-2012-11-29c

Realistically, June’s volatility is below the historical average. It is important to note that the sample size is relatively small, due to the VIX’s short life. Also the relative change/expansion in option volume over time should be considered when looking at historical data. Yet even considering the moves in stocks over the last few years, 10 day HV is only 16.5%:

http://www.ivolatility.com/options.j?period=12&chart=2&ticker=SPY%3ANYSEArca&R=1

In this choppy market, diagonal spreads are dynamite trades. Here are a couple examples that we closed today, after last week’s short option expired:

SPY June 14th/June 21st diagonal call

Short $164 June 14th
Long $164 June 21st

Net debit .07, closed today for .87- 1143% return on cost. Since the net exposure was technically $1, then you could claim that the 4 day return was 87% based on theoretical total exposure/margin. But the odds of that entire $1 being at risk is very low.

Same structure for the IWM:

Short June 14th $99 call
Long June 21st $100 call

Net credit of .01, return of .34. The 98/99 spread incurred a .08 debit for a .50 return.

The beauty of these trades is that exposure is minimized, while the return could be in the stratosphere as you get a free runner after the short leg is closed or expires worthless. If I held these through today, it is possible that .87 could have turned into 1.50 or so, but who is going to be that greedy on a .07 debit when the risk is now not .07 but .87?

I put this on again today, near the highs. I just couldn’t see the S&P going higher than 20 points in front of the FED, and volume was light. Furthermore, the consensus is already talking about buying the FED meeting, so it wouldn’t surprise me one bit to see the market rise tomorrow and early Wednesday just to see it reverse.

Today’s trade:

Short SPY June 21st 165 call for $1.02
Long SPY June 28th call for .95

Net credit .07. Here is how it looks:

spydiag617

Perfection is for the SPY to hover around 165 on Friday, then you get a free look at the long side for a couple days the following week. But if we get a rally to 1665 or so, it is not going to do any significant damage. You just close it for a few cents and come back next week. This chart does not do the trade justice, because there are two separate paths, closing/expiration of the short put to allow theoretical unlimited profits, and closing both legs by Friday. The charting does not show path-dependent risk/reward scenarios.

The odds of cashing on this trade are very high and asymmetric to your risk. I also put on the IWM at 99/100 in the same fashion for a .01 credit. The IWM would have to make an all-time high by Friday to cause any issues on that trade. I like those odds.

VIX Retreats – Futures Hold Premium Ahead of the Fed

If you are a believer in efficient market theory, you have a tough time defending that fantasy this year, and especially this month. Like clockwork for the second time in two weeks, the S&P rode the 10 day moving average right to the 50 day, and bounced off of it like every beginner technical analyst draws it up. It is amazing to watch frankly. The clue yesterday was the low volume drift to the 50, as if it had no real intention to break it, just to tag it.

Volatility in the near month (VIN is the ticker for CBOE near month vol) fell an eye-popping 20%:

vin613

Since the VIX is comprised of rolling near and next month vol, the VIX only fell 12%. After Friday’s close, the VIX will roll to July and August options, one week ahead of options expiraton. This is to diminish the effect of expiration volatility. Little do they realize that the most volatile days in the option cycle statistically occur the week before options expiration. And the end of the expiration cycle is typically low volatility, which of course runs counter to the nonsense you hear on TV about witching and all that blather.

Keep in mind that on Monday, the VIX will be July and a negative portion of August. The formula will be July x 1.25 – .25 August. This effect pulls spot VIX down frequently during that part of the cycle. Virtually no one knows about this effect, certainly it seems no one on CNBC has ever read about how the VIX is constructed. They are just amazed at how it magically falls for no reason.

The futures are now holding a premium to spot VIX, and in July it is a large premium, which will be the front month in 3 trading days. And that sets up the VXX for lower prices if the Fed meeting is a non-event. From what Bernanke has said over and over again, it’s pretty obvious that it will. Who knows what imaginary meaning the pundits at CNBC will devine from his plainspeak.

VX M3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY June2013 16:15:00 16.75 -1.50 18.45 18.45 16.65
VX N3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY July2013 16:21:33 17.70 -0.85 18.70 18.71 17.60
VX Q3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY August2013 16:15:00 18.40 -0.40 18.95 19.00 18.17

VIX Volatility Index values generated at:  06/13/2013 15:12:43

Trade Date Expiration Date VIX Contract Month
6/13/2013 3:12:43 PM
22-Jun-13
15.41 1
6/13/2013 3:12:43 PM
20-Jul-13
16.48 2
6/13/2013 3:12:43 PM
17-Aug-13
17.13 3
6/13/2013 3:12:43 PM
21-Sep-13
17.92 4
6/13/2013 3:12:43 PM
21-Dec-13
19.17 5

So if you were holding June index puts today, they evaporated into thin air. As far as the VXX goes, it could easily see sub 19 in three or four days. This is of course provided the market takes the Fed meeting well. A $1 drop in July VIX futures will send the VXX to $19. That is a reasonable target. The VXX puts are not cheap for next week, so a better strategy may be to butterfly around $19 to get your leverage at very low risk. These puts were very active today.

Here is an example of how you could put this together:

Next weeks VXX expiration:

buy 1 $18.5 call for $1.70

sell 2 $19 calls for $1.40 = $2.80

buy 1 $20.5 call for $.65

Total credit of $.45

Here is what it looks like:

Vxxbutterfly

It has a roughly 2-1 risk/reward payoff, and realistically the risk is lower than what is graphically represented. With the VXX June puts at $19.5 trading for nearly .50, you wouldn’t even make money if the VXX fell to 19. Here you have the odds working for you. You could tighten the butterfly up to 18.5/19/19.5 and pay almost nothing, but then you would need to virtually nail 19 on the dot to make it work.

I sold more SPY diagonals today at 164.5/165 June/June4 for .10. These diagonals have been absolutely marvelous in what essentially has been a sideways market since May 31. They provide an asymmetric risk/reward profile.

If you can believe it, if June ended today, it would be an up month for the S&P, the eighth in a row.

VIX Approaching Highest Level of 2013

Bond auctions and interest rate volatility are agitating equity markets. Today at 1pm, all eyes were on the 10 year auction, which was bid at a level not seen since last August. That caused this to happen to yields on the 10yr:

10yr612

Yields fell ahead of the auction, then reversed course and finished higher. In two hours the yield rose 2.7%. As we know from the Euro charade of the last few years, rapidly rising rates cause agita in global markets. The VIX took that cue and moved higher as well, and stocks sold off.

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-06-12/treasuries-decline-amid-weak-demand-at-u-s-10-year-note-auction.html

Tomorrow, the most volatile of terms, the 30yr, will take center stage, and the Street will stop to watch the results. The Fed meeting can’t come fast enough for those in the fixed income world, for nothing more than a bit of clarity and maybe some rest for soaring yields. Ben will most certainly give a “steady as she goes” bond buying pitch, and we will see what the punditry will try to extrapolate from his comments. Most of which will be imaginary.

While everybody waits for that to occur, the S&P sits precariously on the 50 day moving average. Volume was not particularly heavy, today was more of a drift down than the elevator lower:

s&p612Courtesy of stockcharts.com

The VIX has only seen four days this year at higher levels, so we could see another spike higher as the 50 breaks, or a holding pattern at high levels until the Fed meeting and then a volatility exhale. This is setting up for a nice trade in the VXX. We are sitting at significantly oversold levels, as this chart speaks volumes. Just look at the MACD; you have to go back years to see it at that level:

nymo612

VIX futures are tracking spot tightly, as expiration is only four trading days away. At that point, the VXX will be holding all July, and that allows the VXX to move more efficiently with one futures contract, the front month. As the month wears on and it holds more of the following month, the later month acts as a bit of a stabilizer to spot VIX spikes.

Symbol Contract Month Time Last Change Open High Low
VX M3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY June2013 16:12:51 18.20 1.30 16.45 18.47 16.35
VX N3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY July2013 16:13:01 18.53 0.93 17.20 18.70 17.15
VX Q3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY August2013 16:13:01 18.86 0.71 17.85 19.00 17.80

All of the IWM and SPY short calls in our diagonal spreads are virtually worthless and have been closed out, so any bounce in the market before next Friday will be very profitable. It is almost time to buy VXX puts, but I feel as if there will be a better entry point this week as the S&P dips below the 50 day and shakes out some folks.

Look for retail sales to set the early tone tomorrow.

 

VIX Rising as the 50 day SMA Nears Again

Higher volatility could be here for a while, primarily due to seasonal factors (June is one of the worst months for stocks historically), as well as having a high volatility event on the horizon: the Fed meeting and Bernanke press conference next week.

Of course, the punditry will be reading things into his plain vanilla answers. He will say that inflation is low (almost too low) and job growth is tenuous (he will mention the damage long-term unemployment does to an economy and that he fears pulling stimulus too early) which equals more QE, and for quite some time forward. The pundits will misread this and speculate on the end of QE which will last longer than most expect. Investors may also, which means it could cause more selling in bonds and equities, or more relief buying. Remember that calendar risk and career risk contribute to equity moves in the short-term, and there is no more nervous nelly than a manager with fees and bonuses to protect. Wonder why so many September/Octobers see big sell-offs?

So, the nerves are apparent, if not outright fearful. The VIX rose above 17 again, and the 50 day moving average sits just below. Bonds caught a bid as rates started the day higher and fell about 1%. VIX futures are right in line with spot VIX as June expires next Tuesday:

Symbol Contract Month Time Last Change Open High Low
VX M3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY June2013 16:34:57 16.90 1.30 16.05 17.00 15.95
VX N3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY July2013 16:34:57 17.60 0.90 17.05 17.70 16.92
VX Q3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY August2013 16:34:57 18.15 0.65 17.75 18.30 17.60

Volatility in the term structure of S&P options is slightly backwardated. This implies a rush for gamma, or short-term put profit/protection in the nearest expiration. You may imply this to mean that there is not a simmering greater fear in the marketplace, like an index breakdown or economic deterioration.

 

VIX Volatility Index values generated at:  06/11/2013 15:14:48
Trade Date Expiration Date VIX Contract Month
6/11/2013 3:14:48 PM
22-Jun-13
17.46 1
6/11/2013 3:14:48 PM
20-Jul-13
17.04 2
6/11/2013 3:14:48 PM
17-Aug-13
17.40 3
6/11/2013 3:14:48 PM
21-Sep-13
18.01 4
6/11/2013 3:14:48 PM
21-Dec-13
19.18 5
6/11/2013 3:14:48 PM
18-Jan-14
19.47 6
6/11/2013 3:14:48 PM
22-Mar-14
20.12 7
6/11/2013 3:14:48 PM
21-Jun-14
21.09 8
6/11/2013 3:14:48 PM
20-Dec-14
22.33 9
6/11/2013 3:14:48 PM
19-Dec-15
24.82 10

 

So, just like there was after the jobs number last Friday, we could see what I call a “volatility exhale” next Wednesday, the only reason being that the Fed meeting is in the past. So, selling volatility in the form of calendar spreads or owning VXX puts could be interesting. We will discuss that next week.

In the meantime, I’ve been a fan of IWM and SPY diagonals. Here is an example of one trade I made today:

Sell IWM June 14th $98 call for .90 and buy the June 21 $99 for .92 for a net debit of .02. This is the kind of trade that works for you, as volatility is holding up the short end, right in front of massive time decay. Anything left after Friday is pure profit provided the IWM settles below $98. So far this is working to perfection. Hopefully, you end up with a runner for next week. Same for the SPY, 164-165 actually paid you to own it and leaves you with very little downside risk.

I also dabbled in a LULU calendar, selling June against July at $70 for $1.40.

Will Interest Rate Volatility Cause Equity Volatility?

In case you’ve ignored markets for a month, interest rates have made a very impressive move. Meanwhile, the media punditry loves to wield the old axioms that bond money is far more intelligent than stock money. Is this true? History will tell you that it certainly is not. If bond money was so smart, why were they lending to Greece for all that time? Or better, why are non-investment grade corporates getting the kind of bid that only A or better bonds did before. And who in their right mind would lend at Treasury type rates for 10 to 30 years to a company in the rapidly changing handset industry. That industry is littered with corpses. Those investors are already taking a big hit:

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-05-21/apple-bonds-stick-buyers-with-280-6-million-loss-as-rates-climb.html

So, over-indulgence in risky bonds is not a new story, but now it appears that some may get a hard lesson in duration. Duration is that ugly beast that eats bond values during periods of volatile or rising interest rates. Suddenly a 1% shift in the yield curve makes an 8% hole in your long-term bond. And folks may just stare at their statements at the end of the year wondering who told them they were, ahem, “risk-free”.

So quick look at what the 10 and 30 year yields have done lately. The CBOE used to have a forward swap index that was a proxy for interest rate volatility, but they apparently stopped publishing that data. I feel that it would be a useful data point, to gauge how current rate movements compare to past events, maybe as a predictive gauge of larger rate moves.

30 Year bond rate:

30 year

10 Year:

10 year

Courtesy of Stockcharts.com

Clearly these moves are shocking some folks. Those are 60 basis point moves in one month. And the Fed is still buying 90% of all new treasury issuances:

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-12-03/treasury-scarcity-to-grow-as-fed-buys-90-of-new-bonds.html

What does this mean? First of all, the punditry is wrong about tapering and wrong about the timing probably. Just because the economists thing the Fed will taper this fall, it does not mean they will. The economists are using their crystal ball to project certain job and inflation metrics into the future, and if there is one group of people that are consistently bad at their job, it’s these guys. Furthermore, people don’t like to take Ben at his word, they have to read things into what he is saying. WIth inflation at such low levels, he is contending with a two-pronged enemy, that is not signalling a taper in any way.

Yet, regardless of what people want to hear versus what is true, fear is creeping into the bond market, and that can affect stocks. First, it provides a more attractive place for certain people to park money. Like an automatic stabilizer, the bond market will take in money at better yields. That leaves less for stock allocation. Secondly, higher yields have a slowing effect on the economy, making financing costs more prohibitive to investment, from cars to homes, to corporate cost of capital. Slower spending, slower investment, tougher environment for stocks.

It will be interesting to see if rate volatility equates to equity volatility as as the year moves on.

The VIX had a quiet day as did the futures:

Symbol Contract Month Time Last Change Open High Low
VX M3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY June2013 16:24:09 15.60 -0.20 15.60 15.85 15.40
VX N3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY July2013 16:24:13 16.70 -0.20 16.65 16.85 16.50
VX Q3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY August2013 16:15:00 17.45 -0.25 17.55 17.65 17.30

And volatility historically likes to ebb a bit as the June cycle wears on; although the median is telling you that the market has had some rough Junes.

2013-06-10 20_46_09-Microsoft Excel non-commercial use - VIX-Wave-2012-11-29c

Of all seasons, summer is the weakest, so if you start hearing the “summer rally” stuff floating around, just be aware that the summer is #4 of 4. It also can be quite volatile, as we saw in 2011.

 

VIX to Break Out?

It appears that we’re approaching a sort of “show me” moment in the market right now, where the VIX appears to want higher percentages and the S&P is nearing a support line (50 day sma) that it has held religiously since last October. In today’s algo-bot market, where the vast majority of trades are made by artificial intelligence, trends seem to last longer and technicals are heavily respected, so this may be a critical juncture for 1-3 month market direction.

(I apologize to readers for my recent absence; I’ve been dealing with a confluence of events, including the CFA exam, and food poisoning, but I should have time to post 3-5 times per week going forward.)

If the 50 day is decisively broken, a lot of folks will be stopped out, that is just the fact of the matter. They do not debate it. Whether there are others to step in on POMO faith, during interest rate volatility, and questionable macro and seasonal factors will be very interesting.

2013-06-05 17_00_00-SPY - SharpCharts Workbench - StockCharts

Courtesy: Stockcharts.com

In the meantime, the VIX has in my opinion been very well behaved as the S&P has fallen 80 points, or 4.7% in 10 trading days. Last year as this seasonal fall was occurring, on it’s normal May schedule as opposed to late May early June, the VIX saw levels well above 20. What followed was a summer which saw the VIX explore depths not seen in several years. So, we are at a bit of a crossroads here, IMO.

Nothing has changed frankly, except the month. Macro data is still stinky to meh, but not awful. So it is BLATANTLY obvious that the Bernanke is not even close to turning down the money machine. This can’t be more clear. Furthermore, where are rates going to go with core inflation going LOWER? Forget about core inflation, oil and gasoline are lower than last year. He may print just to reach the inflation mandate:

2013-06-05 16_38_19-Trimmed Mean PCE Inflation Rate - Dallas Fed

Source: Dallas Fed

So, futures are tracking the VIX very closely

Futures

Symbol Contract Month Time Last Change Open High Low
VX M3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY June2013 16:22:36 17.05 0.95 16.40 17.05 16.25
VX N3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY July2013 16:15:00 17.70 0.60 17.25 17.70 17.15
VX Q3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY August2013 16:15:00 18.20 0.40 17.90 18.25 17.84

While the actual VIX term structure is front loaded with vol:

VIX Volatility Index values generated at:  06/05/2013 14:58:14
Trade Date Expiration Date VIX Contract Month
6/5/2013 2:58:14 PM
22-Jun-13
17.84 1
6/5/2013 2:58:14 PM
20-Jul-13
17.19 2
6/5/2013 2:58:14 PM
17-Aug-13
17.51 3
6/5/2013 2:58:14 PM
21-Sep-13
18.06 4
6/5/2013 2:58:14 PM
21-Dec-13
19.13 5
6/5/2013 2:58:14 PM
18-Jan-14
19.37 6
6/5/2013 2:58:14 PM
22-Mar-14
20.09 7
6/5/2013 2:58:14 PM
21-Jun-14
21.03 8
6/5/2013 2:58:14 PM
20-Dec-14
22.15 9
6/5/2013 2:58:14 PM
19-Dec-15
24.63 10

Notice that the front month VIX future is lower than the back month, whereas the actual June S&P options have higher implied volatility than July. So, calendar spreads selling near-term vol and owning time seem to be a potential strategy here, provided the market holds levels and doesn’t break down.

On the VXX front, the note has now just crossed 50/50 ownership of the June and July contract, so big moves higher will be hard to come by, but a significant bounce can deflate it mightily. I’ve been dabbling with June puts out 2-4 weeks at $17 and $18. As you can see, the futures are not even near threatening backwardation, and are still solidly earning negative roll.

Straight long for a bounce play, the XLF 19.50 weekly calls for next week look attractive if you feel like the 50 sma will show support.

Outlook: Vol tends to hang tough in June, as it is the second worst month of the year for the Dow and 3rd worst for the S&P. Yet, just getting by the stupid job number on Friday tends to deflate some vol by itself. I call it stupid because it has a margin of error of +/- 100,000 jobs, and pundits spaz over 10k here or there. Idiot television. Of course, they ignore the revisions, which are historically positively biased.

 

 

Volatility Sleeps as S&P Falls Nearly 40 Points Intraday

Theoretically, you could say that the VIX should have risen well above 20 today. Just the 40 point high to low move intraday implies at least a 20 VIX in my mind:

40 pts high to low / 1687 index = 2.37% x sq. root of 252 trading days (15.87) = 37.62 volatility.

Of course, that is part of the fun in modeling derivative prices: demand determines the key pricing element of an option, the implied volatility, or expected standard deviation (square root of the variance, or in essence the deviation from the average price over a certain period). Just as I discussed in the last post that the option market (re:VIX) was underpricing call options as the S&P made a 7% move off of the April lows.

Call options over the last month were making hundreds of percent in days. Now if you believe that the market displayed a key reversal, (it is still May remember, and June is the second worst month for stocks, just thought I’d mention that) you can still get puts uber-cheap, since the VIX barely noticed today’s move. Same for calls if you’re bullish. Straddles may make a nice bedfellow if vol picks up or if you’re nimble enough to trade them both ways.

The VIX is just not interested in any kind of market move. The put/call ratio hit extreme levels, not seen in years yesterday:

The VIX futures are bored stiff:

Symbol Contract Month Time Last Change Open High Low
VX K3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY May2013 16:58:33 13.17 -0.38 13.17 13.17 13.17
VX M3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY June2013 17:01:19 15.30 -0.13 15.25 15.70 15.00
VX N3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY July2013 17:01:18 16.40 -0.11 16.32 16.65 16.05

June futures actually fell in a sign of complete faith in the Bernanke. And what does this mean?

2013-05-22 18_26_00-Futures Lumber Chart Daily

Price targets on the S&P are getting almost comical now at the brokerages. And we all know, that those knuckleheads are just as bad OR WORSE, than individual investors. They raise them at the highs and lower them at the lows:

http://seekingalpha.com/article/1455311-wall-street-strategist-year-end-s-p-500-price-targets?source=google_news

Who knows, maybe this is the 25% S&P type year of decades past. But GDP and revenue growth existed back in those days, so we are flat out in sentiment stampede if this is going to occur.

I digress. Bottom line, options are cheap and today didn’t change that.

 

Markets Upwardly Volatile

One of the odd quirks of the VIX, (to me anyway) is that when markets chase higher, or there exists herding behavior causing performance panic in the markets, the call implied volatility doesn’t act like put volatility and rise dramatically, causing the VIX to rise. I suspect that the reason lies in that there are always call sellers regardless of market conditions, but not always put sellers when things get dicey. Thus, no imbalance of supply/demand on call IV.

Yet, you can make a fortune due to this fact. Take a calls on the SPY for June for example:

2013-05-14 19_41_55-SPY Options _ SPDR S&P 500 Stock - Yahoo! Finance

 

The 170 calls for June 7th rose 200% or so today. If you bought an equivalent call three weeks ago, you would have turned roughly 10 cents into $5. Look at the 160 calls, obviously trading for at least $5. That return, depending on your expiration, would be around 5000% over the last three weeks.

So, low volatility in a market such as this gives it to you both ways, in uber-cheap protection and major upside participation. Straddles may be a nice option if you are waiting for an inevitable dip but want to ride the herd at a nice price.

Expiration for the futures is in one week:

Symbol Contract Month Time Last Change Open High Low
VX K3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY May2013 16:39:33 13.55 -0.11 13.65 13.85 13.45
VX M3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY June2013 16:39:33 15.05 -0.07 15.10 15.20 14.95
VX N3-CF S&P 500 VOLATILITY July2013 16:39:32 16.10 -0.14 16.15 16.20 16.00

That means that there is a five week option cycle coming up as opex comes before VIX expiration. That generally has implications for the market in the short-term and we will cover that later this week.

I apologize to readers for the sporadic posts. I’m dealing with the impending CFA exam, so the posts will be limited until after June 1st.

Volatility Retreats as Complacency Reigns

Now that everyone is comfortable with May being a breeze, let’s take a look back at how May 2012 unfolded…..

2013-05-02 12_39_27-SPDR S&P 500 ETF Chart - Yahoo! Finance

The market came back from a mid-month April dip to hit highs for the year on May 1st. On May 2nd, it tried to sell-off, but the buy-the-dippers were quite ready for action, and closed it higher than the open. It rose 50 or so S&P points in the last week of April into the first week of May. Look familiar?

Notice how the wicks got long in mid-May as the market battles induced wild swings.

The first two days of May are historically bullish for the market, coming in positive over 70% of the time. The same can not be said for next week. Earnings are over after next week, so the market is going to be left with the loneliness of the sour economy, and “the Bernanke’s” (still entertaining: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PTUY16CkS-k)  ability to prop it up. (More succinctly, give traders and investors the confidence that his actions enable them to feel safe buying stocks.)

Complacency is here in the VIX option market:

http://www.schaeffersresearch.com/commentary/content/blogs/does+the+latest+vix+price+action+reveal+complacency/trading_floor_blog.aspx?single=true&blogid=115883

And the VIX its itself just occasionally rolls over to murmur, then falls back asleep:

VIX Volatility Index values generated at:  05/02/2013 15:14:59
Trade Date Expiration Date VIX Contract Month
5/2/2013 3:14:59 PM
18-May-13
12.97 1
5/2/2013 3:14:59 PM
22-Jun-13
13.81 2
5/2/2013 3:14:59 PM
20-Jul-13
14.47 3